Aggregate Demand Curves in General-Equilibrium Macroeconomic Models: Comparisons with ... Non-Market Valuation in New Zealand: Comment. Geoff Kerr and ..... larger marginal revenue for Z but the same marginal cost as the monopoly and so ... gains by
Jan 7, 1987 - 19 Keren A, Billingham ME, Weintraub D, Stinson EB,. Popp RL. Mildly dilated ... In: Braunwald E, Mock MB, Watson J, eds. Congestive heart ...
This document is an advising tool written by a Berkeley Study Abroad adviser to ... eligibility requirements, academic, housing, application and other logistical details .... Calendar. Course. Paper. College or school within the university. Faculty.
The chess chip divides into three parts: the move generator, the evaluation function, and the search control. â« 3.1. Move generation. â The move generator is implemented as an 8 Ã 8 array of combinatorial logic, which is effectively a silicon ch
Blue whale vocalizations around New Zealand. 2. Kibblewhite et al (1967) analyzed low-frequency sounds that were recorded in 1964 from recorders off New. 35. Zealand's North ... Figure 1 - Pressure waveform and spectrogram of four-unit call produced
Miss Masonhad information re water plants. DR. CROKERsaid she realised information of this kind must exist in notebooks 'etc. but it should be published.
frugivorous pigeon which has probably had a long evolutionary history in New Zealand (Fleming,. 1979). As with most pigeons, its defensive behaviour when threatened is to take flight or hit out strongly with its wings (R.E. James pers. obs.). Its nes
The island was farmed by Europeans from 1832, first privately and ... station, has left a legacy of several buildings: houses, woolshed ..... national importance for threatened vertebrates of .... two major danger points with respect to rat risk. But
outline our concern that a "yes" decision for ... costs of nuclear-generated power, our lack of input indicates our lack of ... Traditional sources of electricity (and other energy ... necessary and possible must be critically examined .... energy av
Totarolâ¢ is a naturally occurring plant extract with potent anti- bacterial and anti-oxidant properties. â¢. Extracted from recycled Podocarpus Totara heartwood. â¢. Totara is the most abundant source of Totarolâ¢ and is unique to. New Zealand.
Syndrome of Encephalopathy and Fatty Degeneration of Viscera in. New Zealand .... or orange-yellow colour of the livers at necropsy was a striking finding ...
differentiate New Zealand MÄori from other ethnic groups that contribute to ..... body shapes, body shape dissatisfaction .... body image: An integrative guide to.
Les Oxley. Economics Department. Waikato Management School. University of .... amount of capital and miles authorised by Parliament, see Porter (1851), ...
Aug 10, 2018 - permits unrestricted use, distribution, and ..... MÃ£ori or NZ European and use of a MÃ£ori or English language surname (Mr Wiremu/Wil- liams or ...
Nov 15, 2016 - on year-round production of high-producing grass and clover varieties. ...... from pastures and integrated cropâlivestock systems. Renew. Agric.
over SQL Table Definitions: Axiomatic, Algorithmic and Logical Charac- terizations, 10/2012. 426. M. Kirchberg ... gar http://www.pingar.com to provide advice on developing technologies and solutions to augment enterprise .... techniques and then app
09/2013. 443. A.A. Abbott, C.S. Calude and K. Svozil. ... When I graduated, my former Professor of Atomic Physics, Horia Hulubei. (who was a pupil of ... In that state of mind, reading a textbook of quantum mechanics translated from Russian I ...
Preparing for an nZoC Health team role: What is involved? 26. B Hamilton, J ...... school netballers and strategies to address this should continue to be a focus of coach and player development. ..... Highly trained competitive sprint cyclists (n = 1
Apr 22, 2018 - ... Zealand I was a toilet cleaner of all jobs, nobody wanted to employ me. ..... be developed to guide TB elimination efforts in NZ. ... 219â220.
Sep 7, 2016 - vated delayed fluorescence.1a In recent years, several new mate- rials that emit deep blue ... demand, as they minimize the production cost by precluding casting of a separate layer. .... Table 1 Photophysical, thermal and electrochemic
Al Martindale,§ ATC,R, Edward Crowley,* LPT, ATC, Jeff Monroe,∥ MS, ATC,. Russ Miller, a PT, ATC ... collateral ligament sprains in college football players, ... wearing braces often faced a high injury risk to their ..... with 2 schools reportin
Social scientists engaged in empirical researchâthat is, ..... Political and Social Research, ICPSR, and the Data Doc- .... digit representing a subdivision.
Hellenbrand WE, Latson LA, Moore P, Mullins CE, Vincent JA. The Genesis stent: a new low-profile stent for use in infants, children, and adults with congenital ...
John P. Albright,*† MD, John W. Powell,* PhD, ATC, Walter Smith,‡ ... t Address correspondence and repnnt requests to' John P Albnght, MD,.
Journal of the N.Z. Institute of Foresters Inc.
PUBLISHED QUARTERLY BY THE N.Z. INSTITUTE OF FORESTERS INC.
(Incorporating NZ Journal of Forestry and Institute Newsletter)
Don J. Mead School of Forestry University of Canterbury Christchurch
EDITORIAL BOARD John C. Halkett Hamish H. Levack A. Priestley Thomson
BUSINESS MANAGER Ted Bilek School of Forestry University of Canterbury Christchurch
Volatility still (J. Halkett) National Park Centennial (J. Manning)
Rex Monigatti P.O. Box 3541 Wellington Phone 767-318
RECENT EVENTS Forestry Corporation reports (J.C.H.) Family forest company sold (H. Levack) Caption competition winner Native forests on private land (S. Wilson) South Westland - options convassed (J.C.H.) Forest and Rural Fire Association of New Zealand DOC Draft Mining Guidelines Lessons from Scandinavia (J.C.H.) Further staff changes at NZFP Forests Ltd
3 4 4 4 5
5 6 6 6
LETTERS Letters to the Editor
FOREST SERVICE RECORD 65 years of State Forest Recreation - Part I.
(I.G. Trotman and A. P. Thomson)
All other correspondence includ ing subscriptions and changes of address N.Z. Institute of Foresters P.O. Box 12-314 Wellington North New Zealand
Annual rates covering four issues Vol 33/1-4 (1988)
Overseas NZ $37.00 $25.00
COVER Mature Red Beech, Westland. Photo: Ian Platt.
CONFERENCE PAPER Multiple-use indigenous forestry on West Coast of South Island (A. J. Tilling)
ARTICLES Are NZ Pinus radiata plantations threatened by pine wilt nematode Bursaphelenchus xylophilus? (J. Bain and G. P. Hosking) Seasonal growth characteristics of red beech, Corsican pine, ponderosa pine, radiata pine, and Douglas fir nursery seedlings (G. Baker) Forest economics and policy (B. M. H. Sharp and B. B. Hull)
19 22 25
INSTITUTE NEWS NZIF Council activities Award to commemorate NZ Forest Service Thomas Kirk award Journal has new Business Manager
29 29 29 30
NEW INFORMATION Book review: 'The Forestry Sector in New Zealand' (W. R. J. Sutton) DSIR declares war on wasps ....................................... . Inducing trees to flower earlier
N.Z. FORESTRY OCTOBER 1987 1
31 31 32
Forest economics and policy
B. M. H. Sharp and B. B. Hull
ABSTRACT The'economics of deriving raw materials from forests is ,examined. Competitive markets are consistent with the notion of efficiency, although they may not produce results that are fair. Sustainability as an alternative crite rion suffers from problems of commensurability and an inability to identify preferred options when a choice between alternative patterns of use is possible. Given a choice among a number of sustainable use rates, com petitive markets satisfy both criteria. Institutional arran gements are significant variables in forestry policy because they provide a basis for competitive markets and they determine the distribution of benefits and costs asso ciated with use. INTRODUCTION The rate at which many of New Zealand's forest resources are being used is a topic of public debate. Some claim contempo rary use rates are not sustainable. Others express concern that products derived from quality indigenous trees are being wasted. Public debate has also focused on non-market benefits and costs. Forests provide habitat for wildlife and contribute to soil and water conservation. Harvesting trees can result in off site impacts such as increased siltation of rivers, estuaries, and harbours. Some forests have social and cultural values. Expression of these concerns by conservation and preserva tion organizations contributed to a decision to separate the conservation and production functions of the New Zealand Forest Service. The Treasury argued that the objectives of con servation and production were better served by separating the functions of management agencies. The new Forestry Corpo ration is expected to operate on a commercial basis, and the Department of Conservation is responsible for natural resource conservation. Our aim is to consider the economic aspects of using a renewable resource to supply forest industries with raw mate rials. Clearly this supply is provided by a collection of private individuals and firms including the New Zealand Forestry Cor poration. It involves a range of institutional arrangements and includes public and private systems of ownership. Actions by this collection of public agencies, private firms, and individuals will result in patterns of forest use that vary across regions and over time. We do not dispute the biological bounds placed on the notion of renewability. However, to the extent that many future use patterns are possible, determining a given use rate becomes significant. Economic analysis can help solve the problem of determining use rates. Our aim is to introduce and discuss concepts relevant to an evaluation of options for sustainable forest use. The approach in this paper is limited, intentionally so. We do not consider off-site and non-market costs and benefits, nor do we attempt empirical analysis. We intend only to provide a basic background and to outline the significant issues in evaluaThe authors: Basil Sharp is senior lecturer in resource economics at the University of Canterbury; Brooks Hull is Assistant Professor, Univer sity of Michigan-Dearborn.
ting New Zealand forest resource policy. Such an approach
lays important groundwork for analysis of specific forest
resources in New Zealand's rapidly evolving policy environ
DEMAND AND SUPPLY
A complete characterization of the actors in the forestry sector
includes the Crown, private resource owners, the public agen
cies and private firms which use the raw material, and con
sumers of the final products (national and international). To
simplify the dis~ussion, we use a very simple relationship that
might exist between a collection of individuals and firms grow
ing trees and a number of sawmills requiring raw materials.
Demand for Raw Materials
People purchase housing, furniture, books, and newspapers;
all products which use raw materials obtained from forests.
Consumer willingness to pay for these finished products is sum
marized by market demand, a relationship between price and
quantity demanded. It is not unreasonable to expect quantity
demanded to increase as price falls. In addition, demand for a
product can change with changes in income, changes in the
price of related goods, and changes in consumer tastes. For
example, the national demand for furniture made of kauri
might increase as the average level of household income
Demand by mills for the raw materials of forests is therefore a demand derived from consumer demand for final products. Consider the demand for logs, which is derived from the demand for plywood. To determine derived demand we need to know something about demand for the product plywood, supply of other inputs used by mills to produce plywood, and prices of substitutes to plywood. A particular plywood pro ducer's derived demand for logs depends on the price the pro ducer receives for plywood and on the cost of obtaining factors of production such as labour, energy, and machinery. The mill manager's maximum willingness to pay for logs is given by the difference between the cost of non-log factors of production and the revenues obtained per unit of output. Market demand for logs is given by the sum of individual mill demands. The essential point is that consumer willingness to pay for finished products and the cost of non-log factors of production co-determine demand for logs. Supply of Raw Materials The cost of supplying logs reflects the cost of obtaining the right to harvest trees and the cost of harvesting the trees and transporting logs to the mill. Variations in forest owner willing ness to sell are the result of differences in owner objectives for forest management. Owners are likely to delay selling their trees if they expect real stumpage prices to rise sufficiently in the future. Some owners attach positive non-market values to their forests, such as those associated with wildlife, and tend to be less interested in selling. Other owners are only concerned about immediate market value of the forest's logs. Variations in owner willingness to sell cause supply costs to increase with the quantity of logs. The more logs mills wish to purchase, the more the mills must pay per log, since mills must buy logs from owners who attach successively higher value to their forests. A supply schedule expresses this relationship by describing the quantity of logs suppliers are willing to sell at various prices. The supply schedule slopes upward, reflecting the increasing cost of obtaining additional logs.
N.Z. FORESTRY FEBRUARY 1988 25
Equilibrium Markets depend upon, and operate within, a set of institu tional arrangements. Those holding rights to the forest's raw materials are willing to relinquish these rights at various prices. Buyers are willing to buy logs at prices reflecting their cost of production and consumer demand for final products. Market equilibrium price is the outcome of a bargaining process between these sellers and buyers. The price tends to move toward the point where the quantity of logs forest owners are willing to sell equals the quantity mills are willing to buy. Prices in our economic system derive from markets and we typically rely on this mechanism to provide relative values that guide resource allocation and the distribution of goods and ser vices. One of the attractions of competitive markets is that this interaction between willing buyer and willing seller can result in maximum net social benefits, given the existing distribution of income. Efficiency is the most commonly used criterion in economic analyses of resource allocation. In competitive markets, equili brium price and quantity exchanged is described as being efficient. The outcome is efficient because market price is the mill's willingness to pay for the "last log" and is also the cost of obtaining rights to use that log. Price equals marginal cost. At a higher output, the cost of an additional log exceeds its value to buyers. At a lower output, some potential gains are fore gone, since some logs whose value exceeds cost are not exchanged. A requirenlent for efficient operation of the market mecha nism is that participants are able to control and transfer rights to property. The set of forest property rights prior to the reor ganization of the Forest Service is quite different from that existing today. Under the new organizational structure, raw materials produced from state-owned forests gravitate to buyers willing to pay for the full costs of supply. Those pre viously enjoying a subsidy now have to pay competitive prices. Consumers not previously enjoying access to a competitive supply of raw materials now have an opportunity to benefit from competitive conditions. Establishing a system of property rights conducive to market efficiency also carries with it a change in the distribution of benefits and costs. The bargaining process is complicated by concentrations of market power and legal agreements that compromise smooth operation of the market. Large buyers of raw materials might be able to negotiate supply contracts with small forest owners at lower than competitive prices. Long-term stumpage con tracts might have clauses which artificially distort prices. Nevertheless, to the extent that markets are characterized by competition where a relatively large number of mills compete to purchase from a relatively large number of forest owners, the nlarket produces results which maximize net benefit. Welfare Economics Almost without exception, the great works of economics have gone beyond the description and analysis of the workings of the economic system. Appraisal and evaluation of approaches to organizing our econonlic system and managing natural resources falls within the domain of welfare economics, the term for the normative branch of economics. The applied wel fare economist is therefore interested in determining if intro duction of a specific policy, project, or management regime makes people better off than the alternatives. In economics, it is assumed that society's well-being is made up of the well-being of individuals in the society. The individual is the originator of preference and therefore value. It is basically utilitarian in its ethical stance (Olafson, 1973). The propriety of this ethical stance has been examined by philosophers and economists (Rawls, 1971; Page, 1977). The problem of deriving operational indicators of welfare has confronted economists for over one hundred years. The essence of the problem is how to measure individual welfare,
N.Z. FORESTRY FEBRUARY 1988
how to add up these preferences, and how to compare the aggregates. In the case of raw materials obtained from forests, we can use prices as a measure of the value derived from use. Consumers and firms compare the benefits and costs of use, exchanges are made in the market, and we observe prices which reflect the trade-offs made. Prices and other monetary measures provide indicators of value in a market (Just et al., 1982). The appropriateness of using these measures for public policy analysis depends upon the context and held values upon which market decisions are made (Brown, 1984).
TIME Time is important because of uncertainty over the ultimate impacts of current decisions, particularly as they relate to the management of renewable resources. Time also matters because the present generation can influence the resource endowment future generations inherit. Just how contempor ary actions affect future generations depends on techno.logical change, the availability of substitutes, and future preferences. Discounting Growing trees to supply raw material necessarily involves long time periods. A kauri forest nlight take 80 years to reach harvestable age. Even a pine forest might take 25 years to reach harvestable age. Because of these long time horizons, benefits and costs must be discounted to a common (present) time (Barton and Horgan, 1980). We make four observations. First, discounting is a method of placing a relative weight on future benefits and costs; it is not a procedure for calculating future benefits and costs. Future benefits and costs must be established first. For example, if we expect the price of kauri . products to increase over time, this should be included in the projected flow of benefits, not be factored into the discount rate itself. Second, competitive market discipline requires producers to maximize the present value of profits (Samuelson, 1976). If a producer fails to do so, and rights to resources are transferable, resources gravitate to those firms that do maximize the present value of profits. Failure to follow this principle results in inef ficiencies; the nation forgoes real wealth. Third, the relation between the discount rate and resource depletion is ambiguous. It does not necessarily follow that high discount rates result in accelerated depletion of a natural resource. For example, the rate of change in relative prices and poor economic performance of the economy as a whole might reduce depletion rates. Fourth, the discount rate applies to all future flows of benefits and costs; not just "money-valued" transactions. Thus, a comprehensive estimate of the cost of forestry rriust include an estimate of the value of opportunities foregone by using the land for forestry. Intertemporal Efficiency Present-day managers make decisions that influence future flows of benefits and cos~s (Page, 1977). The net present value criterion, as used in cost-benefit analysis, is an intertemporal version of the efficiency criterion. A project is judged to be 'worthwhile' if the present value of net benefits is positive. Cost-benefit analysis describes and quantifies all advantages and disadvantages of a policy, alternative development pro jects, or set of management options. Attention is focused on estimating return, expressed in terms of net present value, to the nation. Barton and Horgan (1980) use this framework to evaluate radiata pine and kauri. All inputs - capital, labour, land, fertilizer, seedlings - should be included at their opportu nity cost to the nation. Benefit estinlates are derived from what consumers are willing to pay for the timber products. All values are time-dated and are expressed in equivalent units. Valuation is particularly difficult for forest investments where horizons are commonly longer than 30 years. This dif ficulty should not be sidestepped too quickly by appealing to
the impact that a positive discount rate has on benefit flows far in the future. Newman et ale (1985) show that the rate of price change, even given discounting and the long production period, is important in determining rotation length. Distribution The efficiency of the present value criterion. is one of its chief virtues. However, proposals based on the present value crite rion might also turn out to be inconsistent over time. Incon sistency follows from the impact that contemporary decisions have on future opportunities. One generation using the crite rion to select a forest use pattern has an impact on future patterns of use. The same criterion followed by the second generation provides another plan. Strotz (1955-6) has shown that the second generation would want the opportunity to revise the forest resource it inherited. This is what Strotz referred to as the intertemporal tussle. Competitive markets allocate resources efficiently for any given distribution of wealth. But markets do not solve the problem of what is a fair distribution of wealth among people at a point in time or among generations. This observation is relevant to forestry because the natural resource has a relati vely long production period and decisions are connected over time. Forestry planning today has implications that span future generations. We cannot rely on market forces ipso facto to pro vide the signals necessary for a fair distribution of benefits and costs. Income redistribution is properly the function of the cen tral government, not the market for logs. Uncertainty Significant uncertainty characterizes the market for titnber and related products. Uncertainty arises from climatic events, technological change, changes in legal agreements, changes in . the world economy, and so on. Consider the uncertainty that surrounds estimates of kauri stand yields and kauri timber prices in 80 years. Uncertainty creates difficulty for economic analysis because there is no universal price for uncertainty and because attitudes to risk and uncertainty vary by circumstance and across decision makers. Even with the uncertainty of plans with a one-hundred-year horizon, Naslund (1977) argues that guaranteeing continuous forest production is desirable. More recently, Mills and Hoover (1982) use portfolio analysis to examine the proposi tion that landowners investing in forestry development seem to be making an 'unwise' investment. They found that forest investments in combination with other investments, such as government bonds, are preferred options. Forestry invest ments were found to be fairly risky if held singly, but desirable as a means to diversify a portfolio of other assets.
WHEN TO HARVEST Processing industries require a reliable supply of raw mate rials. In a competitive market, industries bid for this supply in the market. Forest owners base their harvesting decisions on expected prices. From the forest owner's point of view, timing the timber harvest is a major decision because of the long pro duction period involved, the large investments made in plant ing and management, and the large expected returns per unit area. Sustained Yield Traditionally, forest managers assert that sustained yield is the appropriate management objective. Sustained yield is recom mended on the grounds that it protects the resource base for the longest possible time. For indigenous forests, Froude et ale (1985) define sustainability as: . . . harvesting in a manner consi stent with the rate and type of nat ural replenishment, using methods compatible with the long-term survival of the forest. (p.7)
The Indigenous Forest Policy adopted by the Government in 1975 recognizes the importance of developing logging tech niques which ensure sustained timber yield. While many fore sters remain confident that sustained yield is feasible, efforts to develop suitable techniques are often thwarted by climatic conditions, insufficient funds for research, and long-term log ging contracts (Nature Conservation Council, 1981). There are two difficulties with the notion of sustained yield. The first arises when production involves a number of interac ting resources. A high level of yield from a given unit of land might be sustainable, but only by increasing the use of other resources such as fertilizer. Second, it is likely that many levels of sustained yield are feasible. The question becomes: which sustained yield should be selected? Some advocate a policy of maximum sustained yield by following a planting, thinning, and cutting cycle that maximizes output of stumpage, averaged over many repeated cycles (Samuelson, 1976). The notion of sustained yield is shown in Figure 1.
.~·-·r·_·"" Yield I
I I I G
Figure 1: Sustained Yield If we ignore the cost of establishing the forest, maximum (gross) sustained yield occurs at G. Notice that this does not occur at the point of maximum product (P). Waiting the addi tional (P-G) years means forgoing greater increments to product from growth of younger trees. Of course, there are opportunity costs associated with planting, managing, and har vesting trees. These costs are shown in Figure 1 as yield for gone (BN). They have the effect of increasing the rotation yield to N years. Maximum net sustained yield, gross yield less opportunity costs, is shown as AB (Samuelson, 1976). Optimal Harvesting The absence of benefit and cost valuations over time distingu ishes the sustained yield criterion from the present value crite rion. Economic analysis of optimum harvest date is concerned with costs and returns. Three categories of cost are relevant. First, there is the input of capital, labour, and materials during production. Second, there is an opportunity cost associated with the value of the investment. Third, the land locked into forestry production has an opportunity cost associated with its use. The charge against forest use should be based on the highest net return possible from the best alternative use . Determining the optimum rotation under sustained rotation has received much attention from economists over the years. It is not a trivial exercise. In 1849, Faustmann produced a des cription of the rotation scheme that emerges in a competitive environment. By maximizing net present value over an infinity
N.Z. FORESTRY FEBRUARY 1988 27
of cycles, Faustmann shows that the optimal rotation period is shorter than that obtained under a policy of maximizing net sustained yield. Binkley (1987) shows that economic rotations can be greater than, equal to, or less than the rotation which maximizes sustained physical output of the forest. The rule is summarized as: harvest when annual rental change in interest on the stumpage value
+ standing timber
value of the land
Figure 2 illustrates this harvesting rule. The annual change in stumpage value is given by DSV, interest on the value of stan ding timber is IS, and A V describes the annual rental value of the land. Trees are left to grow as long as DSV exceeds IS+AV. Optimal harvesting occurs at T*. Notice that the maximum value of harvested timber occurs at T'. This is not the economic optimum because it ignores the annual costs of maintaining the resource (IS + AV).
o Figure 2: Optimal Rotation Length
The above method has the advantage that it easily deals with some of the complexities of an ongoing forest operation. The forester need not have accurate information about lifetime growth rates of trees, since the harvesting decision is made on a year-by-year basis based on actual growth. So long as log prices, interest rates, and annual rents are changing smoothly, the harvesting decision requires little information about the future. Once again, the decision to harvest is made each year and is based on actual price changes.
FOREST POLICY Public policy researchers are certainly concerned with describ ing the effect that individuals, groups, and organizations have on decisions by elected and appointed policy-makers. Beyond mere description, however, researchers must explain and pre dict the consequences of changes in institutional arrange ments, particularly changes initiated by Government. We have outlined some economic theory useful in understanding the consequences of changes in governnlent forestry policy. Institutions - laws, administrative procedures, and oper ating rules - provide the basis of market transactions. We have
28 N.Z. FORESTRY FEBRUARY 1988
already noted the role of property rights, a subset of institu tions, in the operation of competitive markets. Formalorgani zations such as government agencies, corporations and state owned enterprises, are manifestations of specific institutions. Each organization has its own set of internal rules and oper ating procedures. A basis for forest policy is found in the divergence between what society expects and the outcomes associated with the existing set of institutional arrangements. Public concern over performance of the Forest Service led to a change in organiza tional structure. The new structure will influence decisions made by those operating within the sector. The primary aim of institutional change was to set up the conditions conducive to efficiency, and we expect to see a change in the level and distri bution of benefits and costs associated with forest resource uti lization. The attendant distribution of benefits and costs may lead to political pressure in the future to further alter institu tional structure in the forestry sector. Institutional change is one of the most potent policy instru ments available. Government policy for economic manage ment and the restructuring of the Forest Service is a significant change in institutional structure. The effects of this change will be seen in the markets for wood products, intertemporal pat terns of resource use, profitability of forest investment, and the contribution of forestry to national economic growth.
CONCLUSIONS Society must make choices about use of its forest resources. In its narrowest sense, economics is concerned with determining optimal policy, with the efficiency criterion providing the yard-' stick for evaluating the expected performance of forest invest ment and changes to forest policy. The criterion does not guarantee sustainable supply, nor can it be expected to pro duce a "fair" distribution of costs and benefits now or across generations. Alternative criteria exist, such as sustained yield, which also help shed light on the problem of choice. Neither efficiency nor sustainability are sufficient criteria for choosing a policy because the probability of adopting a policy depends upon the costs and benefits it confers to individuals and groups within our society. A better understanding of the role of property rights and institutional arrangements, includ ing markets, in the allocation of natural resources and the dis tribution of the benefits and costs associated with use enhances society's chances of using renewable resource in a sustainable way. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS We thank T. Bilek, R. P. Hide, G. N. Kerr, R. Pauls, and two anonymous referees for their critical review of the manuscript. REFERENCES Barton, L.L. and G.P. Horgan. 1980. "Kauri Forestry in New Zea land, A Protagonist's View." N.Z. Journal of Forestry, 25(2): 199 216. Binkley, Clark S. 1987. "When is the Optimal Economic Rotation Longer than the Rotation of Maximum Sustained Yield?" Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 14: 152-8. Brown, Thomas C. 1984. "The Concept of Value in Resource Alloca tion." Land Economics, 60(3): 231-99. Froude, Victoria, et al. 1985. Indigenous Forests of New Zealand: Issues and Options. Issues and Options Paper 198511. Commission for the Environment, Wellington. Gregory, G. Robinson. 1972. Forest Resources Economics. John Wiley and Sons, New York. Just, Richard E., et al. 1982. Applied Welfare Economics and Public Policy. Prentice-Hall Inc., Englewood Cliffs. Mills, W. I. and William L. Hoover. 1982. "Investment in Forest Land: Aspects of Risk and Diversification." Land Economics, 25(1): 33-51. Naslund, Berti!. 1977. "The Principle of Sustained Yield and Optimal Forest Management." Scandinavian Journal of Economics, 79(1): 1-7.
'Nature Conservation Council. 1981. Integrating Conservation and Development. Nature Conservation Council, Wellington. Newmann, David H., et al. 1985. "The Optimal Forest Rotation with Evolving Prices." Land Economics, 61(4): 347-53. Olafson, Frederick A. 1973. Ethics and Twentieth Century Thought. Prentice-Hall Inc., Englewood Cliffs. Page, Talbot. 1977. Conservation and Economic Efficiency. The Johns Hopkins University Press, Baltimore.
Rawls, John A. 1971. A Theory of Justice. Harvard University Press, Cambridge. Samuelson, P. A. 1976. "Economics of Forestry in an Evolving Society." Economic Inquiry, 14: 466-92. Strang, William J. 1983. "On the Optimal Forest Harvesting Decision." Economic Inquiry, 21: 576-83. Strotz, Robert. 1955-6. "Myopia and Inconsistency in Dynamic Utility Maximization." Review of Economic Studies, 23(3) 165-80.
~r INSTITUTE NEWS
NZIF Council activities The full Council met in July, November and February and an Executive consisting of the President, Vice-President, Secretary and Treasurer have met at about monthly intervals. The main highlights of the meetings have been: 1. New Zealand's prestigious forestry award, the Kirk Horn Flask and Medal, will be presented for the first time at the Annual General Meeting in May next year. 2. A NZ Forest Service award will be instituted based on donations received for this purpose. 3. The implementation of the new membership categories has been undertaken. All affiliate members would automatically become Associate members; the election of the first Fellows has begun. 4. An 'Issues Committee' comprising Ms Crozier and Messrs Bunn, Cameron, and Vaughan has been involved in preparing a number of submissions for the Institute.
5. Council has put forward a nomination for the Richard St Barbe Baker Foundation's third Man of the Trees Award. Our President was invited to be part of the nominating committee. 6. The topic of professional registration has been under consideration. 7. The financial state of the Institute has been of concern and efforts have been made to remind those with late subscriptions, to sell more handbooks and to trim costs. 8. Council has also been involved with matters relating to consultants, membership, the journal and general administration.
Preparation for NZIF 1988 Conference/AGM is progressing well Planning for the New Zealand Institute of Foresters 1988 Conference and AGM is well under way. The conference, to be held at the THC Chateau, Tongariro, from 11th-15th May, has the theme "National Lands - Mechanisms of Management" . The technical sessions of the conference address issues and conflicts involving land-use planning, user pays philosophy and the approach and attitudes being adopted by the newly-created corporations and departments to the management of public lands. Full programme details and registration form will be sent to all members. Plan now to attend. For enquiries contact: Dr David Rook, C/- Forest Research Institute, Private Bag, Rotorua. TX NZ 21080 FAX (073) 479 380 Ph (073) 475 899
Award to commemorate NZ Forest Service The NZIF has been the recipient of approximately $6000 from the residual funds of the various social and other groups within the Forest Service. These funds will be utilized by the Institute to set up an annual award for outstanding contributions to practical forestry to commemorate the record of the NZ Forest Service in training competent forest managers. A small committee will be working on the rules and reporting back to Council. It is envisaged that local sections will be responsible for nominations from their region. Suggestions on the name and conditions will be welcomed by Lindsay Vaughan, Harry Bunn and Tom Johnson.
Thomas Kirk award NZ Institue of Foresters has received, through the Royal Society, a silver and horn flask presented to Thomas Kirk by Captain Campbell Walker earlier this century. No doubt the flask was carried and well used by Kirk on many of the botanical expeditions that have led to him being so closely associated with the flora of New Zealand. Kirk's outstanding work on, and knowledge of the forest botany of New Zealand is recognized in plant names and publications. The Institute, through the availability of the flask and a small associated sum of money, now has an opportunity to both recognize Kirk's work and promote similar levels .of endeavour in the wider forestry field. Council of the Institute have agreed to use the flask and money as the basis for an award to be made in alternate years, the Thomas Kirk Award. It is to recognize outstanding contributions to Forestry (in the widest sense) and would consist of the Kirk Horn Flask (held for a month) and a medal to be retained by the winner. The Institute have examined the costs of manufacturing dies and casting medals for this prestigious award and find that the cost is quite substantial. We